Friday, March 26, 2021

Larry McMurtry, leaving well enough alone


 Larry McMurtry tried to demythologize the West, but couldn't.

Larry McMurtry's passing is to be mourned, of course. At his best – The Last Picture Show, Leaving Cheyenne, All My Friends Are Going To Be Strangers and, of course, Lonesome Dove – he was superb, one of the country's strongest, most honest writers.

His masterpiece, Lonesome Dove, an attempt to demythologize the American West, was breathtaking in scope and power. And he created an immortal character in Gus McRae. When McMurtry killed Gus off -- as he did to almost all his most beloved characters -- it was like a death in the family, and I wept like a child.

(Of course, he failed spectacularly at altering in any appreciable way our perceptions of the West. Instead, he added a cast of indelible characters to the myths permanently engraved on the national psyche.)

Sadly -- and I consider this an important qualifier -- he devalued much of his best work with ill-conceived and sub-par sequels.

That's only my opinion, of course. But after reading his sequel to The Last Picture Show, the excretable Texasville, I was deeply shocked. When I eagerly grabbed Some Can Whistle, the sequel to All My Friends Are Going To Be Strangers, my favorite McMurtry work, I was bitterly disappointed, even angry, at how he portrayed Danny Deck in middle age.

And let's not even talk about the prequels and sequels to Lonesome Dove. A writer as talented as McMurtry should have known that what you leave out is just as important -- perhaps more important -- than what you keep in.

It makes me sad to admit -- and perhaps it's just a failing in myself -- that his attempts to continue his characters' stories have tainted my appreciation of the original novels. I feel cheated.

McMurtry at work in his Archer City bookstore.

I sound like an old grouch, but I liked and respected McMurtry. My friend Roy Appleton and I traveled to Archer City years ago to visit his bookstore, Booked Up, which once took up most of downtown. Seeing him at work in his office overlooking the bookstacks was an amazing experience.

One of the signs of greatness is the ability to surprise. And McMurtry's New York Times obituary told me something I never would have expected about the writer who was proud of his ranching heritage and spent most of his life in Texas.

He was a Stanford graduate school classmate of Ken Kesey (counterculture icon and leader of the Merry Pranksters), was briefly included in Tom Wolfe's The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test (his classic take on the Pranksters' wild cross-country bus trek in the 1960s) and eventually married Kesey's widow.

He was, according to his writing partner, quite the ladies man. What could be more surprising than that?


Larry McMurtry: Ladies man?

Wednesday, March 24, 2021

Jim Mahoney, master of The Moment


 Jim Mahoney on Window Trail in Big Bend National Park (Photo by Robert Hart)

Instinct, perception and experience

When Jim Mahoney, my friend and colleague for more than 40 years, died this past weekend, he left behind a body of work that testifies to his position at the apex of the photographic profession he served so well.

As a photo editor at The Dallas Morning News, Jim was an integral part of the team that made The News one of the best photographic newspapers in America.

A perfectionist forced to live in an imperfect world, Jim was a world-class photographer who during a long newspaper career nurtured, mentored and worked alongside a generation of prizewinning photographers.

He was a master at capturing “The Moment,” using instinct, perception and experience to identify the single image that best represented his assignment – be it car crash, city council meeting or intimate interview in someone’s living room.

As a young reporter, I worked with Jim at the Denton Record-Chronicle, where he was chief photographer. After covering a story together, Jim – as a courtesy – would show me the photo he planned to turn in to the news desk.

Invariably, without any discussion between us, his photo illustrated the central theme, the basic idea, the essence of the story I hadn’t finished writing yet. He was, in every sense, a photojournalist, a marvelous combination of photographer, journalist and – most of all – storyteller. 

A wizard of his trade

He was a master of composition and a wizard at the tools of his trade. His photographs were not the products of “darkroom magic.” Most were printed full frame, just as he composed them through the viewfinder. The decisions Jim made in milliseconds in the middle of chaos became beautiful, insightful, startling, shocking and, occasionally, horrifying moments frozen in time.

For years, I displayed a framed Mahoney photograph from those years. He took it at a Denton High football game. It was a wonderous – yes, even magical – image. In a single, wide-angle shot, Jim captured every aspect of Friday Night Lights, at least a decade before the term was even coined. The photo had everything: the marching band, prancing drill team, jumping cheerleaders, cheering fans and both teams running on the field at the same time.

Sadly, I lost track of the photo in one of my many moves. What I wouldn’t give to have it back.

Jim never did anything half way. His darkroom, back in pre-digital days when such a thing existed, was immaculate. Not a speck of dust anyway, chemicals lined in exact rows, countertops gleaming, negatives organized with loving care.

Even outside of work, he was meticulous and obsessive. He mowed his lawn twice a week during the summer because he thought it looked “shabby” if he didn’t.

He also was an excellent, if unimaginative, cook. He insisted on following any recipe down to the letter. I remember one Saturday afternoon when we went to a half-dozen different stores looking for a particular Mexican pepper specified in the recipe he was using to make – wait for it – chili.

After no luck at the second store, I made the mistake of saying, “Jim, let’s just get some damned jalapenos!” He gave me a withering glare and didn’t speak to me for an hour. When we finally chased down the elusive pepper, he shot me a triumphant smile and announced, “Now, we can proceed!”

More than a hobby

Jim was a largely self-taught photographer. It was a hobby that became something more after he returned home from serving two years in the U.S. Army.

 Drafted when he left North Texas State in 1968, Jim expected to be sent to Vietnam. But because he had played trumpet for his high school band, he was sent to West Germany to serve in the U.S. Army band stationed in Wiesbaden.

At the height of the Vietnam War, Jim spent his Army career playing at Octoberfest celebrations and in goodwill concerts across West Germany, an ironic twist of fate that was not lost on him. He later said his greatest honor came when he was selected to play Taps during the primary Armistice Day commemoration at Verdun, France.

At the Record-Chronicle, he presided over a three-member photo staff, including himself. His reputation extended beyond the R-C’s modest circulation area. Talented young photogs beat a path to his door for a chance to work with him, among them Robert Hart, Lon Cooper and Bill Clough.

He persuaded R-C managing editor Frank Kelly to create a showcase for the work of his photo staff. It was called Kaleidoscope, a weekly full page with no ads devoted exclusively to photos of a single subject or event.

Devoting such an extravagant amount of space solely to photos was rare in newspapers of the day. For small dailies like the R-C, it was unheard of.

No explanation needed

But Jim and his staff eagerly took advantage of the opportunity and produced marvelous photo essays on a dizzying array of subjects. Text was kept to a minimal. Jim believed if a lengthy explanation was needed to explain the photos, the photos weren’t good enough. Mostly, Kaleidoscope photos spoke for themselves.

When The Dallas Morning News inevitably came calling, Jim accepted a job as its first photo editor, leaving behind his days as an active shooter. His years on the photo desk coincided perfectly with The News’ rise and reign as a premier photographic newspaper, staffed by some of the best shooters in the nation. That was no coincidence.

Although he took his work seriously, bringing a single-minded dedication and intensity that made some less-focused colleagues squirm, Jim possessed a droll, well-honed sense of humor that he often kept well-hidden. When he shared it with you, it was something special.

I sat next to the photo desk for years, and every so often – as the newsroom on deadline careened and buzzed around us – Jim and I would glance across at each other. With a raised eyebrow or a slight shrug, we would confirm what the other was thinking. “This is a damned crazy way to make a living, isn’t it?”

After years on the photo desk, Jim returned to active shooting, and some of his friends wondered how he would adjust. Turns out, he adjusted quite well and took up where he left off, producing terrific photos regardless of the assignment.

Keeping pace

He employed the same instinct, skill and attention to detail that he had at the front end of his career, easily keeping pace with his younger colleagues. He demonstrated, day in and day out, on every assignment no matter how routine, that the old dog already knew all the tricks.

The photo below was taken by Robert Hart, who worked on the DMN photo desk for years with Jim, on Window Trail in Big Bend National Park, a place where both traveled together several times over the years.

Jim hired Robert at the Record-Chronicle in the 1970s after the latter’s dismal first job out of college at Dean Singleton’s Fort Worth Press.

“Jim was editor, teacher, mentor and friend to an entire generation of young photojournalists,” Robert says. “He led by example – by the way he approached every assignment and by the care he took with every photo.”

Jim, dear friend, your journey is at an end. Rest in peace.